Aaron Judge has broken records and compiled an array of individual honors on his way to becoming one of the faces of Major League Baseball during his career with the New York Yankees. Baseball card collectors have been drawn to the 2017 American League Rookie of the Year and 2022 AL MVP in growing numbers, but what are the best starting points when it comes to Judge cards? Here are our picks.
Things to know before buying
The value of sports cards can fluctuate for various reasons such as condition, print runs, or graded population. Other factors that can cause prices to go up or down include player performance, market trends, and health of the wider economy. The secondary sales market for individual cards of a given sport generally hits its lowest point during the offseason (in other words, you can usually find better prices in the offseason than during the season). My recommendations are not an attempt to promote specific investment behavior or trading advice, but to guide and inform readers about popular and unique cards that are celebrated by the sports card community.
Ultimately, the best cards to collect are always the ones you will enjoy regardless of whether they go up or down in value. The recommendations below should serve as a starting point for cards to consider, but a big part of the fun in collecting is the hunt for the cards you like the most.
“Raw” cards vs. Graded cards
Cards can come out of the pack (their “raw” state) with a wide variety of imperfections that can impact their value. Card grading is a process in a which an expert of the field determines the condition of a card based on a number of factors (including corner sharpness, image centering, print imperfections, and more) and assigns a numerical grade, usually on a scale of 1-10 (with the latter being close to perfect) and sealed in a protective case. There are a number of grading companies, each with their own unique grading scales, but Professional Sports Authenticator (PSA) is by far the largest and most prominent in the industry. Cards graded a “PSA 10” can carry a significant value multiplier compared to raw cards or those graded by other companies.
It’s fine (and often cheaper) to buy cards raw, but if you want to ensure authenticity and/or a minimum condition level and you’re not experienced at determining card condition for yourself, you may want to buy a graded card instead — particularly if you’re buying online and only able to see the card in photographs.
Judge’s 2013 Bowman Chrome #BDPP19 is my best value recommendation based on the number of graded copies and price. It also marks one of his first cards as a member of the Yankees organization, predating his official Topps rookie cards by four years.
Best low-end (~$1-$99) Aaron Judge cards
This is a category for collectors who are on a tighter budget or aren’t as concerned about the long-term monetary value of the cards they buy.
2017 Topps #287 rookie card
I consider Aaron Judge’s 2017 Topps #287 a prototypical rookie card that’s high in demand and affordably priced. Raw versions are currently selling on eBay for around $20 with multiple transactions per day over the last 30 days.
I don’t necessarily blame folks who’d prefer a rookie card that captures Judge at the plate, but the fact that it’s his first rookie card from Topps’ flagship set makes it my top budget-friendly recommendation.
More expensive variations and parallels of this card: Purple, Negative, Rainbow Foil, Image Variation SP (short print), Gold (/2017), Vintage Stock (/99), Black (/66), Mother’s Day Pink (/50), Father’s Day light blue (/50), Memorial Day Camouflage (/25), Clear (/10), Platinum (1/1), Printing Plates (1/1), 65th Anniversary Stamp (1/1)
2017 Topps Archives #62 rookie card
As someone who appreciates the history of the hobby, I felt it was necessary to feature Aaron Judge’s’ 2017 Topps Archives #62 card. The Archives product was created to pay homage to the classic Topps baseball card designs of the past while featuring current rookies and stars. The horizontal look, dual imaging, and bright colors of this card are a tribute to the 1960 Topps design.
Although this is a set that’s not particularly known for garnering high interest on the secondary market for its base cards, the current demand for Aaron Judge rookies combined with the nostalgic aspects of this card design has it selling for around $40-$60 on eBay as of this writing.
More expensive variations and parallels: Grey Back, Peach (/199), Blue (/75), Red (/25), Black (1/1)
Best value (~$100-$499) Aaron Judge cards
This is a category for collectors looking to pay a bit more for cards that have some degree of scarcity and have a better chance at retaining or increasing in value long-term.
2013 Bowman Chrome Draft Picks & Prospects #BDPP19
Before his 2017 Major League debut, Judge’s first official baseball card as part of the New York Yankees organization can be found in 2013 Bowman Chrome Draft Picks & Prospects.
Let me clarify the difference between a player’s first Bowman card and Topps rookie card — a “1st Bowman” card is a player’s first official pro baseball card that comes once they’ve joined a team’s minor league system through free agency or the draft. On the other hand, a Topps rookie card refers to a player’s first card once they debut in the Major Leagues, which, in the modern era, generally includes an “RC” (for “rookie card”) stamped on the front.
Judge’s Chrome base card (chromium cards are shiny and are printed on a thicker card stock than the generally more abundant and flimsier “paper” cards) from 2013 Bowman Chrome Draft Picks & Prospects is my best value recommendation based on the number of graded copies and price. Unlike most of the cards on this list, this set was not offered in big box retail stores (like Walmart or Target) and could only be purchased in hobby shops or online. In most cases, this means fewer cards are printed for hobby-exclusive releases compared to sets with retail formats.
According to PSA, there are less than 3,500 examples of this card authenticated by the company and less than 1,500 have received a Gem Mint 10 grade. Since the card’s grading population is relatively low for today’s standards, raw copies will cost you around $150. (For comparison, there are around 10,000 PSA graded examples of the aforementioned 2017 Topps #287 and more than 5,000 PSA 10s.)
This set also offers numerous refractors and autograph variations that I’d highly consider if you really want to splurge. In 2022, the year he won his first AL MVP award, Judge’s Bowman Chrome DPP Superfractor 1/1 Autograph sold for over $300,000.
More expensive variations and parallels: Refractor, Blue (/99), Green (/75), Gold (/50), Black (/35), Orange (/25), Red Ice (/25), Purple Ice (/10), Orange Ice (/5), Red (/5), Black Ice (1/1), Superfractor (1/1), Printing Plate (1/1)
Note: there is also a mini version of this card that sells for less than the full-sized version.
2017 Topps Chrome #169 rookie card
First released in 1996, Topps Chrome has lit up collectors eyes’ with shiny metallic cardstock and rainbow refractor parallels. Experienced collectors know that Aaron Judge’s 2017 Topps Chrome #169 is his most popular rookie card.
To go with that high demand, it has the highest PSA 10 population on this list with over 6,500 copies graded in Gem Mint condition (but fewer total PSA-graded examples than the paper #287 at less than 9,000). The Chrome base rookie card is a logical starting point for novice or experienced collectors, but the Refractor or Prism Refractor are solid alternatives for those who prefer more limited parallel cards. PSA 10 sales of the base card are currently around $200 as of this writing.
More expensive variations and parallels: Refractor, Negative Refractor, Pink Refractor, Sepia Refractor, Prism Refractor, X-Fractor, Image Variation, Purple Refractor (/250), Blue Refractor (/150), Green Refractor (/99), Blue Wave Refractor (/75), Gold Refractor (/50), Gold Wave Refractor (/50), Orange Refractor (/25), Red Refractor (/5), Printing Plates (1/1), Superfractor (1/1)
Best high-end (~$500+) Aaron Judge cards
This is a category for collectors looking to acquire the most desired Judge cards on the market.
2017 Topps Heritage Real One Autographs #AJ rookie card
Topps Heritage is praised as one of the go-to baseball card sets for rookie autographs. One of the major selling points to Aaron Judge’s 2017 Topps Heritage “Real One” Autographs is that his signature is directly on the card. This may seem like no biggie, but “on-card autographs” are highly desired because many of the signatures in modern collecting come in the form of the player signing a sticker, which is then affixed to the card. It’s just not the same as the player signing the card itself.
2017 Topps Heritage Real One Autographs come in two variations: a base card auto in blue ink and a parallel red ink autograph limited to 68 copies (2017 Topps Heritage harkened back to the 1968 Topps set design). The base auto in various grades is currently selling for over $2,000.That said, I wouldn’t consider this the priciest Aaron Judge card on the market, but it has my vote as his best rookie autograph card.
2017 Topps Chrome Sapphire Edition #287 rookie card
Aaron Judge’’s 2017 Topps Chrome Sapphire Edition #287 is his most expensive base rookie card and is also known for its extreme rarity. 2017 Topps Chrome Sapphire Baseball was released as a premium box set featuring 700 blue sapphire chrome cards, five rookie autographs, 13 parallel cards, and two Superfractor 1/1 parallel cards. Back then, Sapphire could only be purchased as an online exclusive and was a limited release of 250 sets — meaning there were only 250 copies of Aaron Judge’s Base Sapphire RC ever produced. A raw version of this card was purchased for $750 in July, while a Gem Mint PSA 10 example sold for $2,500 in August. I consider this the holy grail of Aaron Judge base rookie cards.
Two other cool Aaron Judge Cards
2021 and 2022 Panini Absolute Kaboom!
Topps has the exclusive MLB trading card license, meaning they are the only card manufacturer that can print Major League team names and logos on their trading cards. Unlicensed cards, like those produced by Panini for baseball, generally garner lower collector interest, but some cards can overcome their unofficial status with an eye-catching design and that’s the case with the Kaboom! inserts. Even more highly sought-after in Panini’s NFL and NBA sets, where they do have league licenses (for the time being), Kaboom! cards have become some of the most popular inserts of the modern era thanks in part to their relative scarcity and comic-book style design. Judge was featured in both the 2021 and 2022 Kaboom! checklists and it’s a perfect fit for a player who has become synonymous with hitting home runs.
2021 Topps Now Field of Dreams Game Autograph and Corn Stalk Relic
In 2021, the Yankees and White Sox played a regular season game at the filming site for the 1989 baseball classic “Field of Dreams.” Judge hit two homers into the cornfield in that game and to mark the occasion, Topps Now — a print-on-demand product used to quickly commemorate milestones and significant performances — produced an autographed Judge card that also featured an MLB authenticated “game-used corn stalk.” Cards featuring pieces of memorabilia have become commonplace in the hobby, but the game-used corn stalk is an unusual one.
Getting the best price
Prices for a certain trading card can vary wildly and fluctuate quickly, making it important to check recent sales of a given card to make sure you’re buying at a fair value. You can check recent sales of an item on eBay by selecting the “sold items” filter on search results. You can also run a search on 130point.com, which is a free site that provides sales data from a number of online marketplaces. There are also several apps that provide more in-depth sales data, often charging subscription fees for full access.
To account for outliers, it’s important to take multiple previous sales into account, not just the single most recent. It’s also important to note the recency of those sales and any real-world factors that could affect changes in value.
Why you should trust us
As a second-generation collector (thanks to his dad’s lifelong passion for sports collectibles), Tyler Holzhammer started collecting cards and attending the National Sports Collectors Convention at 10 years old. He’s continued his passion as a collector into a career, providing sports card content and market analysis for companies like Sports Card Investor and Goldin Auctions. Tyler’s sports card collection is centered around players from his favorite teams, the Los Angeles Rams and the St. Louis Cardinals.
How we selected these cards
We utilize marketplace research databases that provide sports card analysis and sales information, such as eBay’s Terapeak product research tool and CardLadder. We recommended this list of cards by analyzing the values, sales volume, set popularity, and grading population of over a dozen different Aaron Judge rookie cards, while also incorporating the personal preference of an experienced collector.
The Athletic maintains full editorial independence in all our coverage. When you click or make purchases through our links, we may earn a commission.
Further reading
(Top photo by Sam Hodde/Getty Images; all card images: eBay)